|
|
Post by serious14 on Oct 12, 2007 11:39:37 GMT 10
Dibo - are you ignoring that Seo clearly dove after being "nailed" by Jedinak?? The replay _clearly_ showed contact was made...... well, nowhere significant really. It looked nasty at the time, but after seeing the replay and taking Seo's record as a cheating bitch into account, then I reckon the only reason Jedi copped the red was because of the two footedness of it all.
Etc. and so forth.
|
|
|
|
Post by dibo (pron. "DIB-OH") on Oct 12, 2007 11:43:38 GMT 10
Dibo - are you ignoring that Seo clearly dove after being "nailed" by Jedinak?? The replay _clearly_ showed contact was made...... well, nowhere significant really. It looked nasty at the time, but after seeing the replay and taking Seo's record as a cheating bitch into account, then I reckon the only reason Jedi copped the red was because of the two footedness of it all. Etc. and so forth. please yourself, i thought the red was completely justified. |
|
|
|
Post by serious14 on Oct 12, 2007 12:26:15 GMT 10
Yellow with a stern warning at best. By dishing out reds for an offence that looks ten times as bad as it is because someone (Seo) cheated, then all we're doing is further enforcing a "hey kids, it's okay to dive and milk a penalty/card/free kick" culture.
Do you want that sort of thing junking up football for the next 30 years Dibo, do you??
|
|
|
|
Post by dibo (pron. "DIB-OH") on Oct 12, 2007 12:56:57 GMT 10
Yellow with a stern warning at best. By dishing out reds for an offence that looks ten times as bad as it is because someone (Seo) cheated, then all we're doing is further enforcing a "hey kids, it's okay to dive and milk a penalty/card/free kick" culture. Do you want that sort of thing junking up football for the next 30 years Dibo, do you?? seo might have carried on a bit, but the fact remains that jedi hit him high with a two footed lunge. off in anybody's book, no matter if the other fellow shakes his hand and says 'jolly good old chap' afterwards. |
|
|
|
Post by newieutd on Oct 12, 2007 13:11:36 GMT 10
Yellow with a stern warning at best. By dishing out reds for an offence that looks ten times as bad as it is because someone (Seo) cheated, then all we're doing is further enforcing a "hey kids, it's okay to dive and milk a penalty/card/free kick" culture. Do you want that sort of thing junking up football for the next 30 years Dibo, do you?? A Red card offence deserves a red card, no question. How could you argue anything less. Do you suggest that we should base cards on what the tacklee does, regardless of what the tackler does??? |
|
|
|
Post by dibo (pron. "DIB-OH") on Oct 12, 2007 13:13:42 GMT 10
Yellow with a stern warning at best. By dishing out reds for an offence that looks ten times as bad as it is because someone (Seo) cheated, then all we're doing is further enforcing a "hey kids, it's okay to dive and milk a penalty/card/free kick" culture. Do you want that sort of thing junking up football for the next 30 years Dibo, do you?? A Red card offence deserves a red card, no question. How could you argue anything less. Do you suggest that we should base cards on what the tacklee does, regardless of what the tackler does??? ^^^ what he said |
|
|
|
Post by thesandman on Oct 12, 2007 13:14:24 GMT 10
He jumped in with 2 feet and made contact - there's no choice BUT to give a red. When I say he wasn't being dirty, I meant that he wasn't intending to take out Seo. I thought it was nothing more than a desperate attempt to get the ball, I don't think he tried to play the man at all. When I think if a player is dirty or not, I think what his intent is - if he's trying to take out the player, or if he just makes an innocent but poor challenge. serious is right - Seo dove like a bitch. There wasn't much contact, and to make it worse the part of his body that he was holding wasn't even what Jedi touched!! That was pretty much when I started to hate that little bitch... Muscat is certainly a skillful and effective player, I wouldn't try to say otherwise - but I still hate him  Jedi is a top player, and he's only going to keep getting better. It's good to see he's holding up as CB |
|
|
|
Post by Andy on Oct 12, 2007 13:33:31 GMT 10
It was a bad tackle from Jedi and he completely deserved the red.
I'm with Sandman on this one. He wasn't being dirty when he dove in and you can see it because just before he hits Seo, he tries to pull out.
Bad Tackle- yes!
Red card- yes!
Dirty play- no!
|
|
mrkaant
Local league player
Posts: 50
|
Post by mrkaant on Oct 19, 2007 12:09:46 GMT 10
Zullo and Kruse showed there class on the weekend with a polsihed display by each.
pritty unfourtunate tht Ian didnt get to play as, iw as confident he wud make the break through.
Ohh and How good was james Holland, jets number 25,
with him spenny stuey and the uzz, we have probs the ebst CDM in the league
|
|
uncleyellow
Local league player
Yellow Yeah Yellow Yellow
Posts: 130
|
Post by uncleyellow on Oct 19, 2007 12:28:09 GMT 10
Zullo and Kruse showed there class on the weekend with a polsihed display by each. pritty unfourtunate tht Ian didnt get to play as, iw as confident he wud make the break through. Ohh and How good was james Holland, jets number 25, with him spenny stuey and the uzz, we have probs the ebst CDM in the league Spenny part of the best cdm in the league? Big call that!! He was only just promoted to the pitch... Has he stopped back passing or something? |
|
|
|
Post by curious on Oct 19, 2007 12:34:56 GMT 10
Zullo and Kruse showed there class on the weekend with a polsihed display by each. pritty unfourtunate tht Ian didnt get to play as, iw as confident he wud make the break through. Ohh and How good was james Holland, jets number 25, with him spenny stuey and the uzz, we have probs the ebst CDM in the league Spelling isn't your forte eh? Sober up or learn to spell. Your making the place look like the jest forum. |
|
|
|
Post by midfielder on Oct 19, 2007 15:30:16 GMT 10
stlil think Jedi is good enough to play for the Socceroo's. Big call so early in his career without the under 20 & 23 squad I have listed below OZ midfielders who have played over the last three years its a lot of talent to beat. Not saying he has not got it just a tad to early to put him in this class Bresciano, Mark Cahill, Tim Carle, Nick , Carney, David , Emerton, Brett Grella, Vince , Kewell, Harry , Sterjovski, Mile , Thwaite, Michael , Valeri, Carl , Wilkshire, Luke Elrich, Ahmad |
|
|
|
Post by Andy on Oct 19, 2007 15:35:09 GMT 10
DON"T FEED THE TROLL!!!!!!!!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by Bearinator on Oct 19, 2007 16:42:25 GMT 10
Ohh and How good was james Holland, jets number 25, with him spenny stuey and the uzz, we have probs the ebst CDM in the league You are either THE MOST PATHETIC troll we have ever had on this forum, or you have no f***ing idea what your talking about. Or both. Im angry at myself for replying, but you deserved to know |
|
|
|
Post by greenpoleffc on Oct 19, 2007 23:19:59 GMT 10
Bear, I'd go with both.
As for Jedi's red. That was a 2 footed lunge and regardless of his initial intent = red card.
Mind you, the same rule applies to hitting the AR in the Jatz but apparently thats ok nowadays.
Go figure
|
|
